The Boiler Rooms
The boiler rooms operate both online and by telephone,
typically from abroad. They are unauthorized by the
Financial Services Authority. Their websites are slick
and bold. They provide a phone number as well as an
e-mail address, but a telephone approach will reach
only an answer phone.
The promoter claims to be a broker or a bank, depending
on which type of scam it is trying to pull off. Its
name may sound like that of a big-name financial institution,
giving it a ring of familiarity that will strike a
chord with the gullible. Some of the fraudulent internet
banks have claimed to be based in Jersey, Guernsey,
or the Isle of Man, at street addresses that do not
exist, much to the exasperation of local regulators.
The dubious brokers are expert at hard-selling shares
in unknown companies, which, if they exist at all,
are probably not generating revenue. The telesales
people working for the outfit have the standard characteristics
of the con artist. Most live as lavishly as they can,
and an astute few save up to buy a comfortable early
retirement, but they have in common that they are
not interested in giving any kind of genuine service.
In closing sales of shares on the telephone, they
have the knack of conveying gravitas and the right
sense of urgency. The dealers convey the unseen impression
that they are sitting at a dealing deck in smart business
attire but, in reality, they are lounging about in
T-shirt and jeans.
The salespeople represent the stock they are pushing
as a hot investment opportunity. Any who are stupid
enough to send money to this outfit will lose every
penny. The victims tend not to learn from their mistakes.
The outfit will refer you to a website representing
the company whose shares it promotes. The site paints
a glowing picture of the company, no doubt using every
high-tech catch phrase, but it is a work of fiction.
The company’s executives are given track records
with named blue-chip companies and a business education
at a world-class university. If you check with the
organizations, you will find no record of the named
individuals, but it is a hassle to do this and the
fraudsters rely on you not bothering.
The telesales people are paid a commission on sales
of between 10 and 60 per cent of money taken in, which
is high. Once a salesperson has opened up a client,
the lead is passed onto a loader, who proceeds to
load the individual with as much stock as he or she
is willing to buy, within as short a time as possible.
The stock on offer from the fraudsters is likely to
be a classic pump-and-dump. This is a planned sales
campaign which sends the share price artificially
spiralling. The promoters will have bought shares
earlier and made a huge profit from selling out high,
at which point the edifice comes crashing down, leaving
a vast majority of investors holding overpriced stock
that they cannot easily sell.
Sometimes, the approach is not as subtle as this,
but the fraudsters simply pocket the proceeds of any
cheque sent in, regardless of what stock it was intended
to pay for.
The crooks may represent their share-selling campaign
as an IPO or private placing and invite you to subscribe
early at a special price. The dealer may send out
a prospectus. This will have some unrealistic profits
and cash flow projections, and will be full of warnings.
The company may have no revenues, let alone profits.
But some greedy investors will not take the hint.
You will be in and out within a month, the broker
may say, and promises clients a small profit –
big enough to entice them, but not enough to make
them suspicious. To release capital, some clients
will empty their building societies and cash in investment
funds. After buying the new stock, they will never
be able to sell out, but it will not be immediately
apparent. The broker will say clients should stay
invested because of market conditions or the exchange
rate.
The only market maker for the stock will be the broker
who sold it. If the firm refuses to buy the stock
back, it will be worthless. It may allow clients to
sell out, only if they will reinvest in an equally
dubious stock. Either way, the clients will never
see the colour of their money. Before their hope is
entirely shattered, the firm will push the dubious
stock, and others like it, hard. It may launch dog-and-pony
client evenings in top London hotels, and invite dupes
into luxury offices for lunch.
You may ask how such a situation could be allowed
to arise in the first place. An unscrupulous firm
occasionally takes over a struggling but basically
honest company whose good name it exploits. The new
owner will stave off suspicious regulators and others
as the firm rips off clients. The firm will eventually
cease trading and the principals will skip the country,
if they had ever been in it, leaving their highly
paid management team, and probably others, to carry
the can.
In dealing with these wide-boys, it is a case of Don’t
ring us, we’ll ring you. They can and will reach
you if you were remiss enough to give them your telephone
number. If you ring them, your call is likely to be
diverted from a UK line to Croatia, Costa Rica, or
wherever else the outfit is hiding out. Your salesperson
will be using a false name, often with an English
upper middle class ring. Such tactics make it hard
for any suspicious or angry punters to trace the fraudsters.
The jurisdiction will have been chosen because local
police are not much concerned about what businesses
are doing if they are not targeting nationals. If
the police start investigating, the telesales team
simply bolts to another jurisdiction.
Every boiler room collapses but it often re-emerges
under another name like a phoenix from the ashes.
Following a collapse, a secretly linked outfit may
approach the victims and claim to recover the money
they have invested. The catch is that it will demand
an upfront fee. Many fall for what turns out to be
a second scam.
Other Financial Services Scams
Share and other financial services rip-offs have the
same aim and are often run by the same people. Some
are still peddling the notorious Nigerian 419 fraud.
It is a type of advance fee fraud, named after the
section of Nigeria’s penal code which addresses
fraud schemes. The fraudsters will send you, the potential
victim, an e-mail, typically but not invariably purporting
to be from a Nigerian, which contains an ungrammatical
but pedantically polite plea for help. The writer
appears uneducated, a ploy designed to lower your
guard. The request is to make temporary use of your
bank account to deposit large claimed government or
other funds in return for a hefty percentage cut.
Any who respond are asked to pay an upfront fee to
release the cash, and, if they should demur, may be
invited to complete the transaction in Nigeria.
If the hapless mark makes the trip, the fun and games
will only have started. First, the mark will be fleeced
of the fee and second, crooks claiming to be local
police will inform the individual that it was a scam
and demand a further fee to retrieve the funds. They
are part of the same fraud and, if you play along,
you will be throwing good money after bad. The 419
fraud is so well publicized that you should not have
fallen for it in the first place. Victims are reluctant
to complain because the proposition on which they
had allowed themselves to enter negotiations was dubious.
If you want to know more about 419, there are plenty
of websites to help you. My favourite is www.419eater.com
because it publishes real-life scam-baiting correspondence,
where the potential victim puts the scamster to enormous
trouble and ultimately declines to part with money.
Another growing fraud is phishing, where the fraudsters
trick people into revealing their bank account details
and passwords, or similar sensitive information, by
e-mail. They will send out e-mails that purport to
be from a big-name high street bank and carry something
that looks like its logo. The e-mail claims it is
checking accounts, and it asks for your account details
and password. If you oblige, as at least a few do,
the crooks will empty your account.
The victims
Some of the victims may not understand what happened.
For those who do, there is nothing much they can do
to retrieve money invested. Some of the wealthier
victims may themselves be money launderers and crooks,
in which case they can be relied on not to kick up
a fuss about their losses, at least in public. The
vast majority of victims are ordinary people, with
varying levels of financial resources. They have in
common only that they are gullible and greedy. Even
prominent businessmen can behave like children in
a sweetshop.